Exploring the Pros and Cons of Virtual Reality: A Comprehensive Analysis

Exploring Infinite Innovations in the Digital World

Virtual reality (VR) has been making waves in the tech world for quite some time now. With its immersive and interactive capabilities, it has the potential to revolutionize the way we experience and interact with the digital world. But the question remains, is virtual reality any good? In this comprehensive analysis, we will explore the pros and cons of VR, and try to determine whether it lives up to the hype. From its impact on our perception of reality, to its potential benefits and drawbacks, we will dive deep into the world of virtual reality and come out with a definitive answer. So, buckle up and get ready to explore the fascinating world of VR.

What is Virtual Reality?

Definition and Brief History

Virtual Reality (VR) is a computer-generated simulation of a three-dimensional environment that can be experienced through a variety of devices, such as head-mounted displays, smartphones, and gaming consoles. It immerses users in a simulated world, allowing them to interact with virtual objects and environments in a realistic manner.

The concept of VR has been around for several decades, but it was not until the 1990s that the technology began to advance significantly. Early VR systems were primarily used for gaming and military training, but today, VR has a wide range of applications, including education, healthcare, entertainment, and more.

In recent years, there has been a resurgence of interest in VR, driven by advances in technology and the growing availability of affordable VR devices. As a result, the market for VR has exploded, with an estimated value of $11.6 billion in 2020 and projected to reach $72.8 billion by 2024.

Despite its rapid growth, VR remains a relatively new technology, and there are still many questions about its potential impact on society, economy, and culture. As such, it is important to explore both the pros and cons of VR in order to understand its true potential and limitations.

How Virtual Reality Works

Virtual Reality (VR) is a technology that simulates an immersive experience that allows users to interact with a computer-generated environment. The goal of VR is to create a completely different reality for the user, one that can be customized to suit the user’s preferences. To achieve this, VR uses a combination of hardware and software to create a fully immersive experience.

Hardware:
The hardware used in VR consists of a headset, which typically includes a display, sensors, and a camera. The headset is worn by the user, and it displays the computer-generated environment to the user’s eyes. The sensors in the headset track the user’s movements and position, while the camera tracks the user’s head movement. The headset also typically includes audio headphones that provide the user with an immersive audio experience.

Software:
The software used in VR is designed to create the computer-generated environment that the user interacts with. This environment is created using 3D graphics, and it includes everything from simple shapes to complex scenes. The software also includes the algorithms that track the user’s movements and position, and it uses this information to update the computer-generated environment in real-time.

In order to create a fully immersive experience, VR also uses haptic feedback. Haptic feedback is the sense of touch that is simulated by the VR system. This can include everything from a vibration in the user’s hand to a full-body suit that simulates the feeling of being in a certain environment.

Overall, the technology behind VR is complex and involves a combination of hardware and software. The goal of VR is to create a fully immersive experience that allows users to interact with a computer-generated environment in a way that feels realistic. By using a combination of hardware and software, VR is able to create an experience that is both engaging and realistic.

Different Types of Virtual Reality Experiences

Virtual Reality (VR) experiences can be broadly categorized into two types:

  1. Immersive VR: Immersive VR is designed to fully immerse the user in a digital environment, creating a highly realistic and interactive experience. It typically involves the use of VR headsets and handheld controllers to manipulate objects and interact with the virtual world.
  2. Non-Immersive VR: Non-Immersive VR, on the other hand, is less immersive and typically uses a VR headset or smartphone to view the virtual environment. It may not require handheld controllers and may rely more on gestures or voice commands for interaction.

Both types of VR experiences have their own advantages and disadvantages, which will be explored in more detail in subsequent sections.

The Advantages of Virtual Reality

Key takeaway: Virtual Reality (VR) is a computer-generated simulation of a three-dimensional environment that can be experienced through various devices. It has a wide range of applications, including education, healthcare, entertainment, and more. While VR has significant potential in enhancing learning and training opportunities, it also has limitations such as cost, accessibility, health risks, and ethical concerns. Understanding both the pros and cons of VR is essential to harness its full potential responsibly.

Enhanced Learning and Training Opportunities

Virtual reality has revolutionized the way we learn and train by providing an immersive and interactive experience that simulates real-world scenarios. It has the potential to enhance the learning process by offering a more engaging and effective way of acquiring knowledge and skills. Here are some of the advantages of virtual reality in education and training:

Increased Engagement and Immersion

One of the key benefits of virtual reality in learning is its ability to create an immersive environment that captures the learner’s attention and increases engagement. It allows students to experience and interact with virtual objects and environments, which can help them better understand complex concepts and retain information. For example, virtual reality simulations can provide students with a hands-on approach to learning about science experiments, historical events, or even complex mechanical systems.

Realistic and Safe Training Environments

Virtual reality also offers a safe and controlled environment for training purposes. It enables learners to practice and refine their skills in a risk-free setting, without the need for expensive equipment or specialized facilities. For instance, medical students can practice surgical procedures in a virtual operating room, while pilots can simulate flight scenarios in a virtual cockpit. This allows learners to develop their skills and confidence in a controlled environment before applying them in real-world situations.

Accessibility and Flexibility

Virtual reality provides accessibility and flexibility in learning and training. It can be accessed from anywhere with an internet connection, and it allows learners to progress at their own pace. This is particularly beneficial for students with disabilities or those who may have difficulty accessing traditional learning environments. Additionally, virtual reality can be used to create customized training programs that cater to individual learning styles and needs.

Cost-Effective and Scalable

Virtual reality can also be a cost-effective and scalable solution for learning and training. It eliminates the need for expensive physical resources and infrastructure, and it can be easily adapted to accommodate large groups of learners. For instance, virtual reality simulations can be used to train large numbers of employees in a company, without the need for separate training facilities or equipment.

In conclusion, virtual reality has significant potential in enhancing learning and training opportunities. Its immersive and interactive nature, combined with its accessibility and flexibility, make it a valuable tool for education and training. As technology continues to advance, virtual reality is likely to play an increasingly important role in shaping the future of education and training.

Increased Creativity and Artistic Expression

Virtual reality technology has opened up new possibilities for artists and creators, enabling them to express themselves in new and innovative ways. With VR, artists can create immersive experiences that transport users to entirely new worlds, allowing them to explore and interact with their art in ways that were previously impossible.

One of the key benefits of VR for artistic expression is its ability to create a sense of presence. Unlike traditional 2D media, VR allows users to be fully immersed in an artistic experience, creating a sense of being physically present in the environment. This can lead to a deeper emotional connection with the art, as users are able to explore and interact with it in a more intimate way.

VR also offers new possibilities for collaboration and community building. Artists can use VR to create shared experiences that bring people together, whether it’s through virtual galleries, immersive performances, or collaborative creative projects. This can lead to new forms of social interaction and community building, as well as new opportunities for artists to connect with audiences and fellow creators.

However, it’s important to note that VR technology is still in its early stages, and there are limitations to what it can currently do. Artists may face technical challenges when creating VR experiences, such as issues with performance, compatibility, and user interface. Additionally, VR requires specialized equipment, which can be expensive and may limit access to certain audiences.

Overall, the potential for increased creativity and artistic expression in VR is significant, but it’s important for artists and creators to approach this technology with a critical eye and consider its limitations and potential drawbacks.

New Entertainment and Gaming Possibilities

Virtual reality has opened up a world of possibilities for the entertainment and gaming industry. With the ability to create fully immersive experiences, developers can now create games and experiences that were previously impossible.

Increased Immersion

One of the biggest advantages of virtual reality is the increased immersion it provides. With VR headsets and controllers, players can interact with the virtual world in a more natural and intuitive way, leading to a more immersive experience. This can be particularly useful for games that rely heavily on storytelling or immersion, such as adventure or exploration games.

New Genres

Another advantage of virtual reality is the potential for new genres of games. For example, VR allows for the creation of “walking simulators,” where players can explore virtual environments at their own pace. This can be particularly useful for players who want to experience a game’s story or world without the pressure of a traditional game.

Re-imagining Classic Games

Virtual reality also allows for the re-imagining of classic games. For example, games like Doom and Wolfenstein have been re-imagined for VR, providing a new level of immersion and interactivity. This can be particularly useful for players who want to experience classic games in a new way.

Training and Education

Virtual reality can also be used for training and education purposes. For example, the military and other organizations can use VR to simulate real-world scenarios, allowing trainees to practice and learn in a safe and controlled environment. This can be particularly useful for high-risk professions where training can be expensive or dangerous.

In conclusion, virtual reality has opened up a world of possibilities for the entertainment and gaming industry. With its ability to provide increased immersion, create new genres, re-imagine classic games, and provide training and education opportunities, VR is poised to change the way we play and learn.

Social Interaction and Therapy Applications

Virtual reality has shown promise in facilitating social interaction and therapy. Here are some ways in which it can be beneficial:

Overcoming Social Anxiety

People with social anxiety often struggle with face-to-face interactions. VR offers a safe and controlled environment for them to practice their social skills without feeling judged or embarrassed. By creating avatars that represent themselves, individuals can engage in simulated social situations and gradually build their confidence.

Therapy for Phobias and PTSD

Virtual reality has been used to treat phobias and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) with positive results. For example, a study conducted by the University of California, Los Angeles, found that VR exposure therapy was effective in reducing anxiety and PTSD symptoms in military veterans. This approach allows individuals to confront their fears in a controlled environment and learn to manage their reactions.

Improving Communication Skills

Virtual reality can also be used to improve communication skills, especially for people with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). A study published in the Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders found that VR-based social skills training improved the social interactions of participants with ASD. By practicing in a virtual environment, individuals can learn how to interpret nonverbal cues and improve their overall communication abilities.

Remote Therapy and Counseling

Another advantage of VR in therapy is its ability to provide remote access to counseling and therapy services. This is particularly beneficial for people living in rural areas or those who have mobility issues. By using VR technology, therapists can conduct sessions with clients in different locations, expanding the reach of their services.

VR can also be used for training and education purposes in the field of therapy. For example, it can be used to train therapists in empathy and communication skills. It can also be used to educate patients about their conditions, allowing them to experience simulations that illustrate their symptoms or treatment options.

In summary, virtual reality offers several advantages in the realm of social interaction and therapy. It can help people with social anxiety, phobias, PTSD, and communication difficulties, as well as provide remote access to therapy services and training opportunities. As VR technology continues to advance, its potential applications in therapy and mental health are likely to expand.

The Disadvantages of Virtual Reality

Potential Health Risks and Side Effects

While virtual reality technology has the potential to revolutionize various industries, it is important to acknowledge the potential health risks and side effects associated with its use. Continuous exposure to virtual environments may cause physical and psychological strain on users, leading to various health issues. In this section, we will discuss some of the potential health risks and side effects associated with virtual reality technology.

Eye Strain and Visual Fatigue

One of the most common health risks associated with virtual reality technology is eye strain and visual fatigue. Prolonged use of virtual reality headsets can cause discomfort and strain on the eyes, leading to dryness, blurred vision, and headaches. This is primarily due to the screens in the headsets being significantly closer to the eyes than typical computer or phone screens, requiring the eyes to work harder to focus on the images presented.

Motion Sickness and Nausea

Another potential health risk associated with virtual reality technology is motion sickness and nausea. The disorientation and disorientation caused by virtual reality can cause users to experience motion sickness, dizziness, and nausea. This is particularly common in virtual reality applications that involve motion or movement, such as simulated driving or flying experiences.

Cognitive Load and Immersion

Virtual reality technology can also have a significant impact on cognitive load and immersion. The highly immersive nature of virtual reality can cause users to become highly focused on the virtual environment, leading to a higher cognitive load. This can cause users to become mentally and physically exhausted, leading to fatigue and decreased productivity.

Physical Inactivity and Sedentary Behavior

Finally, virtual reality technology can contribute to physical inactivity and sedentary behavior. Many virtual reality applications involve sitting or lying down while using the headset, which can lead to a lack of physical activity and increased sedentary behavior. This can contribute to various health issues, such as obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.

Overall, it is important to be aware of the potential health risks and side effects associated with virtual reality technology. By understanding these risks, users can take steps to mitigate them and ensure safe and enjoyable virtual reality experiences.

Cost and Accessibility Issues

One of the primary challenges associated with virtual reality technology is its cost and accessibility. The high cost of VR equipment and the limited availability of such technology in certain regions make it difficult for many individuals to access and experience virtual reality.

  • Expensive Equipment: Virtual reality systems typically require expensive hardware such as VR headsets, sensors, and computers or gaming consoles with sufficient processing power to run the software. This can make it difficult for consumers to purchase the necessary equipment, especially in developing countries or regions with lower economic resources.
  • Limited Availability: Access to virtual reality technology is also limited in regions with fewer technological resources or in areas where internet connectivity is not widespread. This can result in a digital divide, where individuals in urban areas with higher technological access have greater opportunities to experience virtual reality compared to those in rural or remote locations.
  • Compatibility Issues: The compatibility of VR equipment with different devices can also pose a challenge. For instance, a user may need to have a specific gaming console or computer to use the VR headset, which may not be available or affordable in certain regions.
  • Training and Expertise: The use of virtual reality technology often requires specialized training and expertise to set up and operate the equipment effectively. This can be a significant barrier for individuals who lack technical knowledge or training in VR technology.

In conclusion, the cost and accessibility issues associated with virtual reality technology can limit its reach and impact on a global scale. Efforts to improve affordability, increase availability, and promote training and expertise in VR technology are crucial to ensure that virtual reality becomes a more accessible and inclusive tool for individuals worldwide.

Ethical Concerns and Privacy Violations

Virtual reality (VR) technology has been rapidly advancing, providing users with immersive experiences that simulate real-world environments. While the potential benefits of VR are vast, it is essential to consider the ethical concerns and privacy violations associated with this technology. In this section, we will explore the ways in which VR can compromise user privacy and raise ethical questions.

  • Data Collection: One of the primary concerns with VR technology is the amount of personal data that can be collected from users. This data includes information about users’ physical movements, eye movements, and even their emotional responses while using VR. This data can be used to build detailed profiles of users, which raises questions about how this information is being stored, shared, and used.
  • Privacy Violations: Another concern is the potential for privacy violations. For example, VR systems can be hacked, allowing unauthorized users to access sensitive personal information. Additionally, VR systems may be used to manipulate or deceive users, which can have serious consequences for their privacy and security.
  • Ethical Considerations: The use of VR also raises ethical considerations. For example, VR can be used to create highly realistic simulations that can be used to manipulate users’ perceptions and beliefs. This raises questions about the ethical implications of using VR for propaganda or advertising purposes.
  • Mental Health Implications: Another ethical concern is the potential impact of VR on users’ mental health. Prolonged use of VR can lead to feelings of isolation, depression, and anxiety, which raises questions about the responsibility of VR developers to ensure that their products are safe and ethical.

Overall, the ethical concerns and privacy violations associated with VR technology are significant and must be carefully considered as this technology continues to advance. It is essential to strike a balance between the benefits of VR and the need to protect users’ privacy and ensure ethical use of this technology.

Limited Real-World Applications and Job Opportunities

One of the primary disadvantages of virtual reality is its limited real-world applications and job opportunities. Despite the significant advancements in technology, virtual reality remains a niche market with limited practical applications. As a result, the job market for virtual reality professionals is still in its infancy, with few well-paying positions available.

While some industries, such as gaming and entertainment, have embraced virtual reality, other sectors have been slow to adopt the technology. For example, the education and healthcare industries have yet to fully realize the potential of virtual reality, limiting its practical applications. This lack of widespread adoption has resulted in a limited number of job opportunities for virtual reality professionals outside of the gaming and entertainment sectors.

Furthermore, the cost of virtual reality hardware and software is still relatively high, making it difficult for individuals and businesses to justify the investment. As a result, the market for virtual reality products and services remains small, further limiting the number of job opportunities available.

Despite these challenges, virtual reality developers and enthusiasts remain optimistic about the technology’s future. As the technology continues to evolve and become more affordable, virtual reality’s practical applications and job opportunities are likely to expand, opening up new opportunities for virtual reality professionals.

Virtual Reality: The Future of Technology?

Current Trends and Future Developments

The Rapid Growth of VR Technology

Virtual reality (VR) technology has seen tremendous growth in recent years, with a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 44.8% from 2019 to 2026. This growth can be attributed to the increasing demand for immersive experiences and the development of more advanced VR hardware and software.

Advancements in VR Hardware

The development of VR hardware has been a major driver of this growth. VR headsets, for example, have become more affordable and sophisticated, with higher resolution displays and improved tracking capabilities. In addition, the development of VR gloves and other haptic devices has improved the sense of touch in VR experiences, making them more realistic and immersive.

Expansion into New Industries

VR technology has also expanded into new industries, such as healthcare, education, and tourism. For example, VR is being used to treat pain and anxiety in patients, to train surgeons, and to provide virtual field trips to students. This expansion has opened up new markets for VR and has helped to drive the development of new VR applications and experiences.

Integration with Other Technologies

VR technology is also being integrated with other technologies, such as augmented reality (AR), artificial intelligence (AI), and blockchain. This integration is creating new opportunities for VR and is driving the development of more sophisticated and powerful VR systems.

The Future of VR: Predictions and Trends

Looking to the future, it is predicted that VR will continue to grow and evolve, with new innovations and breakthroughs in hardware and software. It is also expected that VR will become more integrated into our daily lives, with applications in areas such as entertainment, education, and communication. As VR technology continues to advance, it will be interesting to see how it shapes and changes the world around us.

Potential Applications and Industries

Virtual Reality (VR) technology has the potential to revolutionize various industries, offering innovative solutions to traditional problems. By providing immersive experiences, VR can enhance learning, training, entertainment, and communication. This section will explore the potential applications and industries where VR technology can have a significant impact.

Healthcare

In the healthcare industry, VR can be used for pain management, therapy, and rehabilitation. Patients with chronic pain or anxiety disorders can benefit from VR-based distraction techniques, which can help them manage their symptoms. Additionally, VR can be used to create immersive environments for therapy, such as exposure therapy for individuals with phobias or PTSD. In the field of rehabilitation, VR can help patients regain mobility and coordination by providing interactive and engaging exercises.

Education

Education is another industry that can benefit from VR technology. Students can experience immersive learning environments that simulate real-world situations, such as historical events or scientific experiments. This can enhance their understanding and retention of complex concepts. Additionally, VR can be used for remote field trips, allowing students to explore different cultures and environments without leaving the classroom.

Entertainment

The entertainment industry has already embraced VR technology, with the development of VR gaming and VR cinemas. VR games offer immersive experiences that allow players to interact with virtual environments and characters. VR cinemas provide a new way to experience movies, with users able to feel like they are part of the action. VR technology can also be used for live events, such as concerts and sports events, allowing viewers to feel like they are in the front row.

Training and Simulation

VR technology can also be used for training and simulation in various industries, such as military, aviation, and emergency services. VR simulations can provide realistic and safe environments for trainees to practice their skills, such as pilots learning to fly or emergency responders practicing for disaster scenarios. This can help reduce the risks and costs associated with traditional training methods.

In conclusion, VR technology has the potential to transform various industries by providing immersive experiences that enhance learning, training, entertainment, and communication. As the technology continues to evolve, we can expect to see more innovative applications in the future.

The Impact on Society and Human Behavior

As virtual reality continues to evolve and gain popularity, it is essential to consider its impact on society and human behavior. While VR technology offers numerous benefits, it also has the potential to create negative consequences. This section will explore the various ways in which VR affects society and human behavior.

The Influence on Social Interactions

One of the primary concerns surrounding VR technology is its potential to replace traditional social interactions. With the rise of VR-based social platforms, individuals may find themselves spending more time in virtual environments and less time engaging in face-to-face communication. This shift could lead to a decrease in social skills and an increased reliance on technology for interpersonal connections.

The Potential for Addiction

Another aspect of VR’s impact on society is its potential for addiction. As with any technology, VR has the potential to be overused and lead to compulsive behavior. This addiction could manifest in various ways, such as spending excessive amounts of time in virtual environments or becoming overly reliant on VR for entertainment and social interaction.

The Effect on Mental Health

VR technology may also have an impact on mental health. While it can provide therapeutic benefits for some individuals, such as those suffering from anxiety or PTSD, it can also exacerbate existing mental health issues. For example, individuals with a fear of public speaking may find themselves even more anxious when using VR technology that simulates public speaking scenarios.

The Ethical Considerations

Finally, the use of VR technology raises ethical considerations, particularly regarding privacy and consent. As VR technology becomes more advanced, it will be able to collect increasingly personal data about its users. Additionally, the use of VR in situations such as therapy or education may raise questions about the role of technology in these contexts and the potential for manipulation or coercion.

In conclusion, while VR technology has the potential to revolutionize various aspects of society, it is crucial to consider its impact on human behavior and the potential consequences of its widespread use. By understanding these impacts, we can work to ensure that VR technology is developed and used responsibly.

Key Takeaways and Final Thoughts

The Potential of Virtual Reality

Virtual reality has the potential to revolutionize various industries, including gaming, education, healthcare, and more. Its ability to create immersive experiences can enhance learning, provide therapeutic benefits, and offer new avenues for entertainment.

The Limitations of Virtual Reality

However, virtual reality also has its limitations. It can be expensive, requiring users to invest in specialized equipment. Additionally, the technology is still developing, and there may be compatibility issues with different devices and platforms. Moreover, virtual reality experiences can be isolating, and there is a risk of addiction or negative effects on mental health if not used responsibly.

The Need for Balance

Therefore, it is essential to strike a balance between the potential benefits and drawbacks of virtual reality. As the technology continues to evolve, it is crucial to prioritize responsible use and ensure that virtual reality is harnessed for its full potential while mitigating its risks.

Further Research and Exploration

Virtual Reality (VR) technology has gained significant attention in recent years, with many hailing it as the future of technology. However, there is still much to be explored and understood about the potential of VR. This section will delve into the importance of further research and exploration in the field of VR, including the potential benefits and challenges of such research.

One of the primary benefits of further research and exploration in VR is the potential for new discoveries and innovations. As the technology continues to evolve, researchers and developers have the opportunity to push the boundaries of what is possible with VR. This includes exploring new applications for VR, such as in the fields of education, healthcare, and entertainment, as well as developing new hardware and software to enhance the VR experience.

Another benefit of further research and exploration in VR is the potential for increased understanding of the technology’s impact on society. As VR becomes more widespread, it is important to consider the ethical and social implications of its use. This includes examining the potential for VR to shape our perceptions of reality, as well as its impact on privacy, security, and mental health.

However, there are also challenges associated with further research and exploration in VR. One of the primary challenges is the need for interdisciplinary collaboration. VR technology touches on a wide range of fields, including computer science, psychology, neuroscience, and more. In order to fully understand the potential of VR and to push the technology forward, researchers and developers must work together across disciplines.

Another challenge associated with further research and exploration in VR is the need for funding and support. VR technology is still in its early stages, and there is a lack of investment and support for research in this area. This makes it difficult for researchers and developers to access the resources they need to conduct meaningful research and development in VR.

Despite these challenges, further research and exploration in VR is crucial for unlocking its full potential. By pushing the boundaries of what is possible with VR, we can develop new applications and technologies that have the potential to transform our lives in ways we never thought possible.

FAQs

1. What is virtual reality?

Virtual reality (VR) is a technology that creates a simulated environment that can be experienced through a computer or a headset. It allows users to interact with a computer-generated world in a fully immersive way, making them feel like they are in a different place or situation.

2. How does virtual reality work?

Virtual reality works by using a headset or a pair of glasses that have a display screen in front of each eye. The display screens show different images to each eye, creating a 3D effect. The headset also tracks the user’s movements and adjusts the images accordingly, creating a fully immersive experience.

3. What are the pros of virtual reality?

The pros of virtual reality include:
* It allows users to experience things that would be impossible in real life, such as flying or exploring other planets.
* It can be used for education and training, allowing users to learn new skills in a safe and controlled environment.
* It can be used for entertainment, providing a new way to experience movies, games, and other forms of media.
* It can be used for therapy, helping people with anxiety, PTSD, and other conditions to overcome their fears and phobias.

4. What are the cons of virtual reality?

The cons of virtual reality include:
* It can be expensive, with some headsets costing hundreds of dollars.
* It can cause motion sickness and other physical discomforts, such as headaches and nausea.
* It can be isolating, as users are often immersed in the virtual world and may forget about the real world around them.
* It may not be as effective for some people as others, depending on their individual needs and preferences.

5. Is virtual reality any good?

It depends on what you are looking for in a virtual reality experience. If you are looking for a new way to experience entertainment or education, virtual reality can be a great option. However, if you are looking for a replacement for real-life experiences, it may not be as satisfying. It is important to consider the pros and cons of virtual reality before deciding if it is right for you.

How virtual reality tricks your brain

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *